Have you ever looked back at your dating history and wondered why you keep attracting the same type of person? It might be that you are dating on autopilot without even realising it.
Maybe every relationship starts with incredible chemistry but eventually fizzles out. Perhaps you find yourself changing your personality to please someone else, ignoring red flags, or constantly trying to prove that you’re worth choosing.
If this sounds familiar, you might be dating on autopilot.
Repeating the same dating patterns doesn’t necessarily mean you’re unlucky in love. Sometimes, it means you’re approaching relationships without understanding what you truly need or what has been holding you back.
On an episode of fetchlove, Sheryl Matthys, pet lovers dating coach and founder of FetchaDate, sits down with Master Certified Relationship Coach Amie Leadingham to discuss conscious dating, relationship readiness, and how to finally break the patterns that keep you from finding meaningful love.
Amie’s story makes the conversation even more relatable. After spending 15 years struggling with dating and repeatedly choosing emotionally unavailable partners, she decided something had to change.
And after doing the inner work, she eventually met her husband.
Here’s what she wants singles to understand about breaking dating patterns and finding a relationship that actually fits their lives.
1. Recognize the Dating Patterns You Keep Repeating

Sometimes, the biggest obstacle to finding love isn’t the people we meet. It’s the patterns we bring into every new relationship.
Amie knows this from personal experience.
She describes herself as someone who had a difficult time dating. For 15 years, she continued putting herself out there, hoping to find love. Her friends even joked that dating had practically become her second job.
But despite all that effort, she kept meeting emotionally unavailable people who couldn’t meet her needs.
Eventually, after experiencing a particularly painful heartbreak, she realized she needed to take a closer look at herself.
She recognized that she was the common denominator in her dating experiences.
Instead of continuing to blame the people she met, she began asking what she could change within herself.
That realization became the starting point of her journey toward conscious dating.
The takeaway: If you keep experiencing the same relationship problems, take time to examine the patterns behind your choices. Understanding what keeps happening is the first step toward doing something differently.
2. Understand the Difference Between Chemistry and Compatibility

One of the biggest dating mistakes Amie made was confusing chemistry and intensity with genuine connection.
She explains that she would meet someone who seemed great on paper, experience incredible chemistry, and feel an immediate attraction.
But there was one important thing missing: compatibility.
Some of those relationships lasted around three months before eventually fizzling out.
Amie also noticed another pattern. When she met someone she really liked, she would start changing herself to become the person she thought they wanted.
Instead of showing up authentically, dating became a performance.
She would adjust her personality, interests, and behavior to impress someone, only to eventually become exhausted from trying to maintain that version of herself.
Sheryl also points out that attraction, physical appearance, and chemistry don’t automatically mean two people will work well together in everyday life.
So what’s the difference?
Chemistry can create excitement and attraction, but compatibility is about whether your values, beliefs, and life goals actually align.
As Amie explains, chemistry and intensity don’t last forever. She discusses how that initial intensity can last around 18 to 24 months, after which the relationship you chose becomes much more important.
The takeaway: Don’t ignore chemistry, but don’t let it make all your dating decisions. Pay attention to the deeper qualities that help two people build a lasting relationship.
3. Do the Inner Work Before Entering Another Relationship

Breaking unhealthy dating patterns requires more than simply deciding to choose different people.
Sometimes, the work begins with understanding yourself.
After her difficult dating experiences, Amie invested time in personal growth. She attended workshops and seminars, read books, worked with a coach, and went to therapy.
She also describes doing what she calls shadow work.
For Amie, this meant addressing the insecurities and internal beliefs that were affecting her relationships.
She realized that some of her feelings of not being good enough came from past experiences. Instead of allowing those experiences to continue influencing her dating decisions, she needed to work through them.
She also encourages singles to examine their limiting beliefs about themselves, dating, and relationships.
For example, believing you’re not good enough can affect the kind of people you choose and what you think you deserve.
Believing that all the good ones are taken can also make you overlook someone who might actually be a good match.
And if you constantly believe relationships are difficult, you may enter new connections with your guard already up.
The takeaway: Before looking for a different relationship, consider what you need to work through within yourself. Healing old insecurities and challenging limiting beliefs can help you approach dating with greater confidence and awareness.
4. Know Your Non-Negotiables Before Choosing a Partner

What does your ideal relationship actually look like?
Not just physically, financially, or based on someone’s dating profile, but in terms of the qualities that matter when building a life together.
Amie encourages singles to identify their non-negotiables, which are the essential qualities and values they require in a relationship.
These aren’t superficial preferences, such as someone’s height or hair color.
Instead, they involve deeper questions:
- Do you both want a family?
- What does ambition mean to each of you?
- How important is emotional safety?
- How do you handle conflict?
- Can you communicate and repair the relationship after disagreements?
- Do your values and beliefs align?
Amie also shares how she reviewed her previous relationships to identify recurring behaviors.
She noticed that some of her past partners struggled with boundaries, frequently lied, and were emotionally unavailable.
Once she recognized those patterns, she became more intentional about looking for people who demonstrated the opposite behaviors.
Rather than repeating familiar choices, she started identifying what a healthy relationship would actually require.
The takeaway: Make a list of your relationship non-negotiables. Knowing what you need makes it easier to recognize whether someone is genuinely compatible with you instead of simply being attractive or exciting.
5. Vulnerability Is What Creates Deeper Connection

Someone can look perfect on paper and still not be the right person for you.
Amie explains that she often works with singles who experience relationships that last around three months before gradually losing momentum.
Even when two people have shared interests, attraction, and several compatible qualities, something may still be missing.
That missing piece can be vulnerability.
According to Amie, vulnerability creates connection.
If you’re only talking about hobbies, interests, and everyday activities without ever discussing the things that truly matter, the relationship may struggle to develop beyond the surface.
Getting to know someone means being willing to have meaningful conversations about values, expectations, emotional needs, and what you both want from a relationship.
It’s not always easy to open up, especially if you’ve experienced heartbreak or disappointment before.
But without that deeper emotional connection, two people can spend time together without truly getting to know each other.
The takeaway: Don’t be afraid to have meaningful conversations. Being vulnerable allows both people to understand each other beyond initial attraction and surface-level compatibility.
6. Stop Trying to Impress Someone and Become the Chooser

This was one of the biggest changes Amie made in her own dating life.
Previously, she would approach dating by trying to impress the person sitting across from her.
She wanted them to like her, so she would sometimes change herself to match what she thought they wanted.
But when she started dating again after doing her inner work, she approached things differently.
Instead of simply going with the flow and hoping someone would choose her, she became the chooser.
She started asking meaningful, open-ended questions:
- Tell me about your family.
- What do you envision in your ideal relationship?
- What values are important to you?
Her goal wasn’t to judge someone or make them prove themselves. It was to understand their perspective and see whether their values aligned with hers.
She also began paying closer attention to people’s actions instead of relying only on what they said.
As she points out, people may tell you exactly what you want to hear in the beginning. But their behavior can reveal something very different.
That shift helped her recognize emotional safety and ultimately find the relationship she wanted with her husband.
The takeaway: Dating isn’t just about making someone like you. It’s also about deciding whether that person is right for you. Ask questions, observe their actions, and give yourself permission to choose.
Be Authentic About Who You Are, Including Being a Pet Lover

Amie also shares an important message for single pet lovers.
If you love animals and your pet is an important part of your life, don’t hide that part of yourself when dating.
Be honest about your lifestyle, your priorities, and the things that matter to you.
She explains that being truthful about who you are helps attract people who genuinely want the same things.
It’s essentially target marketing: the more authentic you are, the better chance you have of connecting with people who appreciate the real you.
Sheryl agrees, emphasizing that pets are part of the family and that single pet lovers shouldn’t feel the need to minimize that connection when looking for a partner.
Your love for your pet isn’t something you need to apologize for or hide to make yourself more appealing.
The right person should understand that your pet is an important part of your life.
The takeaway: Own who you are. Whether it’s your love for animals, your lifestyle, or your personal values, authenticity helps you attract people who appreciate you for the person you really are.
What Does Conscious Dating Really Mean?

For Amie Leadingham, conscious dating is about being intentional rather than simply repeating the same experiences and hoping for a different outcome.
It means understanding your relationship patterns, doing the inner work, knowing your non-negotiables, and recognizing the difference between attraction and genuine compatibility.
It also means being willing to learn.
Amie emphasizes the importance of being teachable. Sometimes, people approach dating believing they should already know everything or that finding love should happen naturally.
But there’s nothing wrong with asking for help, attending workshops, reading books, or working with a professional when you need guidance.
You don’t have to figure everything out on your own.
And perhaps most importantly, conscious dating means remembering that you have a choice.
You don’t have to keep chasing people who cannot meet your needs or changing yourself to fit someone else’s expectations.
You can become more intentional about the relationships you allow into your life.
Watch the Full Conversation with Amie Leadingham on fetchlove
Are you dating on autopilot, or are you making conscious choices about the people you let into your life?
Amie’s journey is a reminder that finding love isn’t just about meeting more people. Sometimes, it’s about changing how you approach relationships.
After 15 years of repeating dating patterns, she finally took the time to understand herself, recognize what she needed, and become more intentional about choosing a partner.
And that shift changed everything.
Watch the full episode of fetchlove with Sheryl Matthys and Master Certified Relationship Coach Amie Leadingham to hear more about conscious dating, compatibility, vulnerability, and finding a relationship that truly fits your life.
You can also learn more about Amie’s coaching and resources at amiethedatingcoach.com.
And if you’re a single pet lover looking for someone who understands your lifestyle and loves animals as much as you do, discover FetchaDate, the dating app for single pet lovers.
Because you shouldn’t have to change who you are to find someone who loves you.
Sheryl
The Pet Lover’s Dating Coach
Episode 2: fetchlove – The Podcast
Watch the first episode of fetchlove, where we explore love, relationships, and the special bond between people and their pets.
Subscribe to our YouTube channel to catch new episodes, expert conversations, and more!