Dating with pets can bring unexpected challenges, especially when the person you’re dating is afraid of your animal. What happens when you really like someone, but they want you to give up a pet you love? It can be just as complicated as being friends with an ex, where boundaries and emotions aren’t always simple.

Real dating questions. Honest answers.

These questions come from members of the FetchaDate community.

Dear Sheryl,

My boyfriend says he’s still good friends with his ex because they ended things on good terms. They occasionally text, catch up, and even meet for coffee. He insists there’s nothing romantic between them, but honestly, it makes me uncomfortable.

I don’t want to come across as jealous or controlling, but I also wonder whether staying close to an ex is healthy when you’re in a new relationship.

Am I being insecure, or is this a boundary worth setting? Can exes really be just friends?

— Wondering About the Ex


When Is Being Friends With an Ex a Problem?

Dear Wondering About the Ex,

Ahhh, the ex who never quite exits the picture! 😅

First, let’s answer your big question: Yes, exes absolutely can be friends. Just because a romantic relationship ended doesn’t mean the friendship, respect, or connection they shared has to disappear.

But here’s the catch: Not every friendship with an ex is created equal.

There’s a difference between two people who have genuinely moved on and maintained a platonic friendship and two people who are still emotionally entangled, even if they insist there’s nothing romantic happening.

And that’s where I’d focus your attention.

Rather than asking, “Should my boyfriend be friends with his ex?” I’d ask, “What does that friendship look like, and how does it affect our relationship?”

Does he openly tell you when they talk or get together? Has he introduced you two? If not, is he willing to do so? Does he respect your relationship when communicating with her? Are there boundaries around what they share emotionally?

Here’s where emotional entanglement can still be happening. For instance, do you wonder if she’s the first person he calls with exciting news? Why do their conversations seem so private? Why does he get defensive whenever you ask about her?

Those details matter more than the fact that they used to date.

And let’s talk about your discomfort.

Feeling uncomfortable doesn’t automatically make you insecure. But feeling uncomfortable doesn’t automatically mean he’s doing something wrong, either.

Sometimes our feelings are telling us something important. Other times, they’re reminding us of an experience where we were hurt before.

The goal is learning to tell the difference.

What Are Healthy Boundaries When Your Partner Is Friends With an Ex?

Have a conversation with him that isn’t about demanding he end the friendship. It’s about understanding what you both consider respectful boundaries.

You might say:

“I understand that you and your ex ended on good terms, and I’m not asking you to erase your past. But I’d like to understand what your friendship looks like now. What boundaries would help us both feel respected in our relationship?”

Then listen.

Does he care about understanding your concerns, or does he immediately dismiss them as jealousy?

And just as importantly, are you willing to hear his perspective?

Because healthy relationships aren’t built by one person making all the rules. They’re built by two people figuring out what works for both of them.

You may discover that his friendship is perfectly innocent and that a little more openness helps you feel comfortable.

Or you may discover that your expectations around former partners are fundamentally different.

That’s not necessarily a trust issue. Sometimes it’s a compatibility issue.

A boundary isn’t simply telling someone what they’re allowed to do. It’s deciding what you’re comfortable with and whether the relationship you’re building aligns with your values.

Fetch Love Dating Light Signals

🟢 EXPLORE: He’s open about their friendship, respects your feelings, and maintains clear boundaries that protect your relationship.

🟡 OBSERVE: Their friendship makes you uncomfortable, or he’s initially defensive, but there’s no evidence of inappropriate behavior. Have the conversation and watch whether his actions help build trust and whether the interactions start to feel more comfortable.

🔴 DON’T EXPLAIN IT AWAY: He hides their communication, lies about seeing her, shares romantic or intimate messages, or repeatedly prioritizes his ex over your relationship while dismissing your concerns.

Here’s what I want you to remember:

You don’t need to compete with his past. But you do deserve to feel secure in his present.

The goal isn’t to make him prove his loyalty by cutting every woman from his past out of his life. It’s to build a relationship where you both understand what loyalty and respect look like today.

FETCHLOVE TAKEAWAY

An ex doesn’t have to be out of someone’s life to be out of their heart. What matters is whether their present behavior gives you a reason to trust them. ❤️


 

Sheryl
The Pet Lover’s Dating Coach

 

Issue #20: fetchadate “Fetch Friday – Ask Sheryl” newsletter
Subscribe here to get our dating tips in your inbox every Friday.

FASCINATING